| Comments: After a coup that killed the royal family and magically locked many refugees out of the land of Lumatere, Finnikin of the Rock has been searching for other exiles, writing the names of the dead in a book. He has hopes that he along with Sir Toph will be able to secure land in order for the exiles to reunite since they are unable to return to their land. When Finnikin receives a message that he must go to the Cloister of Lagrami, he is introduced to a girl named Evanjalin, who has taken a vow of silence but believes she has walked the dreams of Balthazar, a prince of Lumatere believed to be dead. Finnkin and Sir Toph try to continue their quest, but it soon becomes clear that Evanjalin has taken charge, and that she has an agenda they couldn’t even dream of. With a cast of interesting characters, including a young thief and a few surprises I don’t want to spoil, this quest fantasy (which is light on the fantasy and heavy on the quest) is a gem of high level thematic questions, interesting characters, and bits of humor despite the sadness.
I got an ARC of this last January and was told if I liked Graceling, I would love this. Since Graceling is one of my favorite books ever, I took this seriously, but I couldn’t get past page 30. When it made our Mock Printz list after its publication in February, I kept hoping it would drop off the list. But it never did. So the week before our Mock Printz, I finally forced myself to sit down and read it, giving myself a quota of 100 pages a day so that I would finish it in time for the awards. It was a struggle. But once I hit page 250, I was totally hooked. I breezed through the rest, desperate to learn the secrets of Lumatere and Evanjalin. I was hooked by the slow boiling romance and the dramatic reveals. But it shouldn’t take until page 250 to like a book. I understand that a lot of world building had to go into this, but the pacing really needed work. That being said, other than the pacing, this is a work of perfection. The language is gorgeous, the characters are deep, and the book really addresses some interesting questions about heritage and country and identity. It wasn’t until the romance finally kicked in that I got sucked in, but if you like long quest narratives with high stakes, you should read this.
And in the interest of full disclosure: I actually voted for this as my number one Mock Printz choice.
Reviewed from ARC received from Candlewick. |